Comprehensive vs third party car insurance

Average customer rating: 4.3/5

We do not compare all brands in the market or all products offered by all brands. At times certain brands or products may not be available or offered to you. Learn more about how our comparison service works.

Top 3 things to know about comprehensive vs third party car insurance

1

Cover for your car

The main difference between comprehensive and third party car insurance policies is the level of cover they provide for your own vehicle.

Learn more

2

Different levels of cover

Comprehensive car insurance generally provides the most coverage while Third Party Property Damage is the most basic policy that can cover vehicle and property damages.

3

What CTP doesn’t cover

Although it’s technically a form of third party insurance, Compulsory Third Party insurance doesn’t cover damages to vehicles and property.

Learn more

It pays to compare

Simple to use

It only takes a few minutes to look for new car insurance policies that suit your needs.
 

Compare & save

Compare car insurance coverage options and quotes from a range of providers side-by-side.
 

Switching is easy

It’s easy to switch to a car insurance deal that better suits you and your budget.

Why compare with us?

Our smart comparison technology is trusted, free, safe and secure.

Trusted by Aussies

Since 2012 our smart comparison technology has helped over 6 million Aussies compare & search for savings.

Free to use

When you buy through us, our partners pay a commission, which keeps our service free for you. We don’t markup any of the prices on our website.

Safe & secure

We take data privacy and security seriously, and will only use your information with your permission. You can read our full privacy policy here.

Meerkat Arm

We believe the best decisions start with a comparison.

We’re proud to have helped millions of Aussies look for a better deal.

4.3 / 5
Based on 2,697 reviews
23 million comparisons and counting
4.5 / 5
Based on 1,732 reviews
Ratings as of 06/06/2024.

A guide to comprehensive vs third party car insurance

Updated 9 August 2024
Written by Kenneth Young
Reviewed by Adrian Taylor

What’s the difference between comprehensive and third party car insurance?

The main difference between comprehensive and third party policies is the level of cover provided for your own car.

Comprehensive insurance generally offers the most coverage, while third party car insurance covers your vehicle in limited situations.

All types of car insurance (except CTP) generally cover damages to third party property and vehicles.

Before purchasing any policy, always read the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) for more details on inclusions, exclusions and policy limits.

Comprehensive car insurance

Third Party Fire and Theft

Third Party Property Damage

What about Compulsory Third Party (CTP) insurance?

Does comprehensive insurance include third party cover?

Yes. Comprehensive car insurance policies typically cover damage to third party vehicles and property. However, they don’t offer the same cover as CTP insurance which covers bodily injury, so you’ll still need CTP as well as your comprehensive policy.

Which is better: comprehensive or third party car insurance?

Man driving his carWhile comprehensive insurance offers more coverage than third party car insurance, some things you might like to consider when selecting a car insurance policy include:

  • What level of cover you can afford
  • The condition of your car
  • The cost of repairing and replacing your vehicle.

If you have an expensive car, having comprehensive car insurance could provide peace of mind knowing it could cover damages to your vehicle if you’re in a car accident. This type of cover could also replace your car for either an agreed value or its market value if it’s written off. However, insurance premiums for comprehensive policies are generally more expensive than those for third party car insurance.

For a more budget-friendly option, third party insurance coverage can cover damages to other cars and property, and offer limited cover for your own car. You won’t have all the benefits that come with a comprehensive policy, but third party car insurance policies could provide financial protection if you cause accidental damage to someone else’s car.

Meet our car insurance expert, Adrian Taylor

Adrian Taylor
Executive General Manager – General Insurance

As Executive General Manager of General Insurance at Compare the Market, Adrian Taylor is passionate about demystifying car insurance for consumers, so they have a better understanding of what they’re covered for. Adrian’s goal is to make more information available from more insurers, to make it easier to compare and save.